
Dear Mik Chicks,
Family vacations are quite the big deal in our house. Members of the extended family are often invited and quite a few vacations have been enjoyed with in-laws, grandparents, siblings, etc. But now a major vacation is being planned. Like an overseas, potentially-once-in-a-lifetime vacation. Here is the conundrum. Certain family members have been involved in the planning. The destination was chosen based on the needs and desires of extended family. Now it seems that other family members are asking if they can come.
Family vacations are quite the big deal in our house. Members of the extended family are often invited and quite a few vacations have been enjoyed with in-laws, grandparents, siblings, etc. But now a major vacation is being planned. Like an overseas, potentially-once-in-a-lifetime vacation. Here is the conundrum. Certain family members have been involved in the planning. The destination was chosen based on the needs and desires of extended family. Now it seems that other family members are asking if they can come.
How many is too many? How do we close the door on tag-alongs without hurt feelings? Should family members really vacation together? Or will we end up playing out the plot of a Ben Stiller movie? Help,
Nervous
Nervous
Dear Nervous,
We feel for you. Family vacation planning is always complicated. If you don’t tread lightly, they can be the breeding grounds for future grudges and gripes. And sometimes all it takes is ONE uncooperative person.
Case in Point (which you may skip if you don't want anecdotal Heidenstecker background info) (and who really does?) (Real Advice is below): in 2006 when Lisa and I (Maddie) made the trek to visit the recently-mentioned German family, there dwelled Vacation Hot Water and we dove in—head first. We landed in Dusseldorf (exhausted), and were taken to a Certain Tante's house where she had a delicious meal waiting for us. As we sat down, we couldn’t help but notice the nervous twitch in this Tante's eye. But we ignored it, as we were pretty hungry. (And exhausted.)
I (Maddie) sat, stuffing my face mit Kartoffels as Mom and Tante chatted it up. My German is horribly, horribly broken, so I was mostly going off body language and inflection. Soon this Tante was sitting rigid as a board and zeroing in on Lisa with laser-grade intensity.
Mom's body language consisted of bursting into tears and bolting for the Badezimmer.
This Tante shrugged and smiled at me. “Mochtest du mehr Kartoffeln?”
Onkel P. (Did I mention he was there? No? Probably because he didn’t say much or do much—just passed me the Kartoffeln whether I Mochtested them or not.) made dull eye contact with me for five solid seconds. No words. We didn’t need them. It was some hardcore familial bonding that transcended time and language.
Apparently, the Tante in Question was irritated because we did not have a clear enough plan as to what days we’d be staying with what relatives. Lisa had neglected to plan the trip Germanly enough.
In the end all was good, but we learned this lesson when it comes to extended family:
Plan those vacations. Plan them up right. (some extended family may be optional)
Now for the Real Advice…
We at Connecting Now tend to be inclusive rather than exclusive. We hate to put an arbitrary number on how many is too many. . . . and some crowds are Just Splendid! But again, some family may be optional . . . So, Nervous, with that in mind:
Tell your extraneous extended fam that you’ve already set up an itinerary. Give them your flight and hotel information and tell them that if they want to get on board, they’re welcome to. Be polite but clear that you have a definite plan in place, and while you’re not stopping them from coming, you’re also not going to change your trip on their behalf.
If they are willing to do the legwork and not force you to be the team captain for the entire crew, then only the people who really want to go will end up doing so, and nobody can say that you didn’t invite them. Chances are that if each extra person is in charge of planning, booking and financing everything for themselves, your numbers are going to be fairly low—and hopefully it will be the right relatives—the ones who are easy-going enough so you can actually enjoy the Adventures of a Lifetime—even if it resembles a Ben Stiller movie.
Because that's what we hope for you!
Vacationing Readers!
How do you avoid family vacation disasters? What would you suggest to Nervous?
Anxiously Awaiting Your Replies,
Maddie and Lisa
How do you avoid family vacation disasters? What would you suggest to Nervous?
Anxiously Awaiting Your Replies,
Maddie and Lisa



I say 'Bravo" to your advice! Firm and yet welcoming. Timely advice with the holidays approaching.... whether you are going over the river and thru the woods to Grandma's house or having the whole famdamily over to your own house for turkey dinner. (what was I thinking???!!)
ReplyDeleteI couldn't add a word to your perfect advice! My siblings and I had a Jamaican vacation 16 years ago in December, provided by our generous younger brother (so like Lisa's mushy inside person she mentioned on FB). We each planned our own itinerary, except for breakfast on the beautiful back porch and dinners together.This worked perfectly (as far as I know ;-))
ReplyDelete[I loved seeing Germany via Lisa and Maddie.]
Just shoot me now and put me out of my misery! Extended get togethers will be the death of me...Yes, that is evil of me but. being truthful in my old age! LOL
ReplyDeleteI love extended family trips. LOL Of course on Thanksgiving, Joe and I will stop by our daughter's home (where the family is gathering) with a quick hello, and then we are heading out for a perfect trip for two (2) yep, just the two of us! :)
ReplyDeleteNervous here. Besides a solid snort after reading the opening comic (hahahahahaha), I was steadily nodding throughout your response. I like the idea of being inclusive without the pressure. Pressure sucks. Especially family pressure. And mayhaps I have some German in me, because this trip is being planned to a T (or would that be a "tay?")
ReplyDeleteMy new mantra? Those who can keep up are welcome; the rest can stay home and watch Meet the Parents on DVD. Here's hoping I can hold to that.
@Melody-mae - We won't shoot you for being truthful, but the readers (and Maddie) MAY insist on a conundrum or two to back up said evilness ;)
Great advice! Last year we did a family pilgrimage to a cousins wedding. It was pretty stressful. We had a 9 month old and we had to be on his schedule. We were okay with that but others weren't. I guess the best advice is to be flexible once the event starts.
ReplyDeleteI've always wished I had a large extended family... except when I'm planning a vacation. When the three of us (husband, son, and I) take our one BIG vacation each year, I always plan everything in advance. It makes vacation relaxed and organized, which I appreciate (even if I'm German only by marriage). We do visit relatives, or host relatives in our home occasionally, but vacationing falls into a different category for me.
ReplyDeleteBecause I grew up in a small family, I never had much chance to travel in large groups. Once my husband and I went to a wedding in California and spent a day at Universal Studios with the wedding party: about 20 people of mixed ages. We moved from place to place in a slow pack, and no matter what some people wanted to do at one particular moment, other people had good reasons not to do that. Nobody wanted to be rude and split apart from the others; but we did spend a good deal of time having long discussions about what to do next. I wanted to go, and do, and see, not discuss--so it was kind of maddening.
I agree with your advice... let everyone who wants to come along know about your plans, and let them decide if they're willing to follow those plans. One of the advantages of having a very large group might be that you could split into sub-groups for some activities--some could go shopping, some could visit museums/historic sites, some could sit around by the pool, etc. Without knowing your destination and its amenities, I don't know if that would be possible... but it would certainly make things easier!
Elaine
Excellent advice, Ladies! To avoid the "Johnny-come-Latelies," one might communicate with standard information which includes a deadline date and time.
ReplyDeleteGreat advice! I'll be passing it along to a friend who has in-laws that make every occasion an extended family vacation, much to her dismay.
ReplyDelete